Lexington Records

PVA neighborhood

Home sales in New St, Miller St Prop, & S Mill Commons, Lexington, KY

10 sales recorded by the Fayette County PVA in the New St, Miller St Prop, & S Mill Commons neighborhood between September 2024 and September 2026. "Neighborhood" here is the PVA's appraisal-neighborhood code, not a subdivision or HOA boundary.

10Recorded sales
5Arm's-length
$439,000Median price (arm's-length)
$236Median $/sq ft
$814,900Top sale · 512 S Mill St
Median price per square foot by month — New St, Miller St Prop, & S Mill Commons
$216 $257 $298 Oct 24: $234 Nov 24: $216 Jan 25: $279 Jun 25: $264 Sep 25: $298 Sep 24 Feb 25 Jul 25 Dec 25 May 26 Sep 26
scroll →
DatePriceAddressOwner of recordSq ft$/sq ftValidity
April 5, 2026none514 S BroadwaySprague & Miller Lexington Holdings LLC1,738—AFFILIATED ORGANIZATIONS
March 27, 2026$85,000240 Miller StGallagher Benjamin C0—VACANT LOTS/ BUILDERS
Feb. 6, 2026none505 Plunkett StZiccarelli David L1,738—CLOSE RELATIVE SALES/TRANSFERS
Oct. 16, 2025none509 Plunkett StScattertown Ky LLC1,738—TRANSFER-TAX NOT PAID
Sept. 16, 2025$573,000517 Lawrence StNusbacher Kenneth And Laurie1,924$298CHANGED TRANSFERRED SALE
June 16, 2025$410,000508 S BroadwayMussler Kevin Douglas Ttee, Mussler Nevada Family Dynasty Trust1,738$236ARMS LENGTH TRANSACTION
June 2, 2025$459,900529 Lawrence StKsh Enterprise LLC1,574$292ARMS LENGTH TRANSACTION
Jan. 31, 2025$439,000533 Lawrence StMathews Charles W1,574$279ARMS LENGTH TRANSACTION
Nov. 21, 2024$375,000505 Plunkett StZiccarelli David L1,738$216ARMS LENGTH TRANSACTION
Oct. 15, 2024$814,900512 S Mill StWarriner Family Investments LLC3,488$234ARMS LENGTH TRANSACTION

Source: Fayette County Property Valuation Administrator (PVA) sales list, retrieved Sept. 12, 2026. Sale prices are as recorded by the PVA; the owner column is the owner of record at retrieval, not necessarily the buyer in that sale; "arm's-length" reflects the PVA's own sales-validity code.